According to The Guardian, graduates are finding it harder than ever to secure jobs in their fields.
While 61% of students who graduated in 2022 had full-time work 15 months later, a significant portion of these roles were non-graduate positions. Data from the Office for National Statistics reveals that only 60.4% of graduates in England aged 21-30 secured high-skilled jobs, with another 26.4% in medium or low-skilled employment. This challenging landscape adds another layer of difficulty for candidates, as appearance biases continue to shape hiring decisions.
A survey cited in HR Magazine found that appearance-related biases still persist in the workplace, with 25% of workers ranking appearance as the most important factor when meeting someone for the first time. This was followed by personal hygiene (23%) and someone’s job title (17%). Despite efforts to create more inclusive environments, the reality is that candidates who “look the part” are often at an advantage. In this article, we’ll explore common appearance biases and provide tips on how recruiters can combat these biases to foster a more inclusive and diverse workplace.
Common appearance biases to watch out for
A study published in the Harvard Business Review shows that candidates’ physical features and attire from profile pictures can heavily influence hiring decisions. Certain accessories, such as glasses or a beard, as well as formal attire like a coat and tie, can give candidates an edge. When a job seeker “looks the part,” inferred from their photograph, they are more likely to succeed in getting hired. This demonstrates how deeply ingrained visual cues are in recruitment, leading many employers to favour those who meet specific appearance expectations.
For example, while wearing glasses doesn’t correlate with intelligence, there is a strong visual association between glasses and intellect or sophistication. As a result, candidates who wear glasses may be perceived as more professional. However, with the rise of online retailers offering contact lenses, candidates can now opt for contacts to align with personal or professional preferences. For some, contact lenses are also more convenient as they don’t interfere with eye contact whilst addressing common vision issues like presbyopia, myopia, and astigmatism. This choice further illustrates how subtle appearance decisions can affect hiring outcomes.
Decades of research have further shown that attractive employees are more likely to be hired, promoted, and climb the corporate ladder faster than their peers. Attractive bosses even tend to receive higher performance ratings. Experts suggest that this is not simply because of beauty, but rather the positive traits we often attribute to attractive individuals. These biases can lead to a skewed perception of a candidate’s potential based on their appearance rather than their actual abilities or qualifications.
How recruiters can combat appearance biases
To foster a more inclusive recruitment process, HR professionals must actively work to minimise the impact of appearance biases. As we discussed in a previous post, this can start with having a more diverse candidate pool. Recruiters can collaborate with agencies and networks specialising in placing candidates from underrepresented backgrounds. This secures a diverse pool of candidates for all positions, especially in executive roles.
Moreover, job descriptions should be written to emphasise transferable skills and competencies rather than focusing on unnecessary qualifications or jargon. This helps attract candidates from a wide variety of backgrounds, ensuring that no one is deterred from applying based on their educational or professional experiences.
Blind recruitment can also be implemented, where information such as a candidate’s name, background, or educational institution is hidden during the initial selection process. By focusing solely on qualifications and relevant experience, recruiters can make fairer, more objective decisions.
Lastly, while digital recruitment tools are useful, employers must be cautious of creating new biases. Research from 2021 reveals that 21% of UK adults lack the essential digital skills needed for daily life, and only half of low-income households have internet access. Candidates from disadvantaged backgrounds—whether due to age, education, disability, or income—may be disproportionately affected by the shift to digital hiring. A combination of digital tools and human oversight can prevent digital exclusion and facilitate a more equitable process.




